HomeMy WebLinkAbout09/29/2021 SPECIAL MEETING AGENDA PACKET
____________________________________________________________________________
CITY COUNCIL 345 6th Street, Suite 100, Bremerton, WA 98337 (360) 473-5280
WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 29, 2021
CITY COUNCIL “SPECIAL MEETING”
5:00 PM – Via Zoom Webinar
Washington State Department of Health
“Certificate of Need Overview”
Presented by
Christie Spice, Acting Assistant Secretary
Health Systems Quality Assurance Division
and
John Williams, Executive Director
Office of Community Health Systems
To help reduce the spread of COVID-19, and until the Norm Dicks Government Center is open to
the public, the City Council will continue to hold their meetings via Zoom Webinar.
The Special Meeting is open for the public to listen in, but there will be no opportunities for input.
➢ Members of the public are invited to join the Zoom webinar by clicking on the following link:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84144083605?pwd=YzlOYXQ3Q0ZWbkxCNVpFamQvWHpHZz09
➢ Or iPhone one-tap:
US: +12532158782,,84144083605#,,,,*408318# or
+16699006833,,84144083605#,,,,*408318#
➢ Or Telephone: Dial (for higher quality, dial a number based on your current location):
US: +1 253 215 8782 or +1 669 900 6833 or +1 346 248 7799 or +1 929 205 6099
Webinar ID: 841 4408 3605
Passcode: 408318
CERTIFICATE OF NEED (CN) PROGRAM OVERVIEW
September 29, 2021
Christie Spice John Williams
Acting Asst. Secretary Executive Director
Health Systems
Quality Assurance
Facilities, Construction,
Certificate of Need
Washington State Department of Health | 3
Agenda
Overview of DOH’s role in heath care
regulation
History of Certificate of Need (CN)
General goals of CN
Process and timeline
Kitsap County specific information
What is outside of CN scope
Q & A
Washington State Department of Health | 4
Our Mission, Role and Values
Department of Health’s mission: Protect and
improve the health of people in Washington.
Health System Quality Assurance Division role:
Assure people have access to safe,
equitable, and high quality health care
services through regulation and education.
Our values: Patient safety, access to care,
equity, innovation and engagement.
Washington State Department of Health | 5
Health
Professions
Community
Health
Systems
Customer
Service
Health
Systems
Oversight
Investigative
and Legal
Services
Health Systems Quality Assurance
Office of the Assistant Secretary
H
Washington State Department of Health | 6
Community Health Systems
Construction Review
•Building science solutions
•Safe and healthy physical environments.
•Code
compliance
Certificate of Need/Facilities
•Hospitals
•Behavioral Health
•Ambulatory surgery
•Hospice care
•Nursing homes
•Kidney dialysis
Emergency Care Systems
•Emergency
Medical Services
•Trauma System
•Cardiac & Stroke System
Rural Health
•Improve access to healthcare for rural residents.
Washington State Department of Health | 7
Capacity Development Pipeline
Certificate of
Need
Construction
Review
Facility
Licensing
Certificate of Need (CN) History
Washington State Department of Health | 9
History of CN
1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020
1st CN program
NY State
National Health Planning and
Resources Development Act
•Federal Funding
•Mandate
Effectively all
states have CN
Federal program
sunsets
1974 -WA State
passes legislation
creating CN.
1989 -WA State healthcare
planning system sunsets.
•CN moves from DSHS to DOH
•Legislature removes capital
expenditures from CN review
2010 -WA State
Courts found that
CN does not violate
Anti-trust laws
2015 -WA State Courts
found that CN cannot
consider merger as
reviewable
Centers for Medicaid/Medicare
begins to shift reimbursement
structure to contain cost
Washington State Department of Health | 10
34 states currently have CN laws.
A few others have laws with similar approaches.
Temple University Center for public
Health Law–CN states in yellow CN States Non-CN States
CN in Washington
People in communities have access to
needed, safe and affordable healthcare.
Washington State Department of Health | 12
“Access to Needed, Safe, Affordable Care”
$
$
•Transparent and public process
•Projects are financially viable
•Applicant provide high quality care
•Best Alternative for community
Washington State Department of Health | 13
Laws and Rules pertaining to CN
RCW 70.38
Health Planning and Development
WAC 246-33
Health Planning and Development
Washington State Department of Health | 14
Establish new Expand capacity
Hospitals (Acute and Psychiatric)X X
Nursing Homes X X
Kidney Dialysis X X
CMS cert. Home Health & Hospice X X
Non-CMS Health & Hospice
Ambulatory Surgery Centers X X
Office Based Surgery Center
Hospice Care centers X X
Outpatient clinics
Assisted Living Facilities
Residential Treatment Facilities
Facilities Regulated by CN
Washington State Department of Health | 15
Tertiary Services
•Intense Inpatient Rehabilitation
•Open Heart Surgery and PCI
•Organ Transplant
•Some Intensive Care:
•Specialty Burn Units
•Intensive Obstetrics
•Intensive Nursery Services
•Intensive Pediatric Services
Complex services…
needing sustained volumes…
…to maintain quality.
Washington State Department of Health | 16
Core Tenets of CN
Need Financial
Feasibility
Structure &
Process of
Care
Cost
Containment
Washington State Department of Health | 17
General Process
Need Financial
Feasibility
Structure &
Process of
Care
Cost
ContainmentApplicantApplication
CN Screening and Review
Opportunity for public
comment/hearing
Application
Approved or
Denied
X
Legal
challenge
possible
Health law judge,
appellate, superior courts
Washington State Department of Health | 18
CN compliance monitoring
Need Financial
Feasibility
Structure & Process of Care
Cost
Containment
Applicant
Application
CN Screening and Review
Opportunity for public
comment/hearing
Application
Approved or
Denied
X
Legal challengepossible
Health law judge, appellate, superior courts
Project
completed
on time, in
budget
Monitor
complaints if
capacity is
exceeded
CN compliance
Kitsap County Hospitals
St. Michaels
•Silverdale Campus
•Bremerton Campus
•336 beds
Naval Hospital Bremerton
•25 beds
•Not regulated by DOH
Washington State Department of Health | 20
Hospital History in Kitsap Co.
1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020
1903 Puget Sound Naval Shipyard
1918 City General incorporates
(later Olympic then Harrison)
1943 FDR Hospital opens
(later Puget Sound Hospital)
1956 Puget Sound and Harrison merge
Silverdale
campus opens
1974 -WA State
passes legislation
creating CN.
New campus
In East Bremerton
West Wing
added Beds moved between
campuses
New Silverdale
Tower complete
Orthopedic tower
construction
1981 –CN adds 72 beds
1976 –CN adds 18 beds
1998 –DOR for
Silverdale campus not reviewable
Affiliation
With CHI
VM/CHI Merger
2009 -CN approved
2013 –DOR for affiliation
not reviewable
2017 -CN addition of all beds
at Silverdale campus
Washington State Department of Health | 21
Out of scope of CN program
•Whether a provider wants to stand up a
facility
•Whether a provider closes a facility
•Emergency surge pressures
•Personnel disputes
Washington State Department of Health | 22
Capacity Development Pipeline
Certificate of
Need
Construction
Review
Facility
Licensing
Washington State Department of Health | 23
Facilities Licensing programComprehensive approach
Construction Review Certificate of Need
Technical Assistance Available
•All aspects of
licensing process
•Any stage of
development
•Process
•Q&A
•Tips
•Feasibility
•Construction
•Re-use and
adaptation
•Licensing issues
•Facility types
•Process
Washington State Department of Health | 24
Issues/Questions from Council
Overview of CN and history
•How it pertains to hospitals in Kitsap
•Impacts to quality and healthcare
Are providers (facilities) required to
provide a level of service
Concerns over temporary ED closure
Concerns over staffing issues
Concerns over working conditions
Questions?
John Williams
john.williams@doh.wa.gov
360-236-2950